$405,000
4 bd|1.5 ba|2,476 sqft
36 N Custer Ave, New Holland, PA 17557
Listed by Berlanco Realty
Pending
Listing description
Property consists of a well built and kept 2 story brick Victorian home on a .36 acre level, landscaped lot situated on one of Gap's prettiest streets. The main floor contains a foyer area, formal living and dining rooms with pocket door divider, updated oak island kitchen, family room addition w/brick Fireplace w/propane insert, half bath and laundry room. The upper level contains 4 bedrooms and a full bath. There is floored attic storage with stairway access. The full basement has an "L" shaped rec room and utility and storage areas with an outside entrance. There is a 7'x45' wraparound front porch. Updates include insulated replacement windows, 200amp electric service and more. There is a detached 2 car garage and paved driveway. Great location with easy access to major routes and shopping. Don't Miss It!!!
Rooms by level
How the bedrooms and baths are distributed across the floors, as reported by the listing agent.
- Main level1 half bath
- Upper level4 bedrooms · 1 full bath
Facts & features
Interior
- Bedrooms
- 4
- Bathrooms
- 1 full · 1 half
- Living area
- 2,531 sq ft
- Heating
- Radiator, Hot Water
- Cooling
- None
Property & construction
- Property type
- Residential · Detached
- Architectural style
- Victorian
- Year built
- 1922
Lot & parking
- Lot size
- 0.36 acres (15,682 sq ft)
- Garage
- 2 spaces
Financial
- Price / sq ft
- $146
- HOA dues
- None
Listing details
- MLS #
- PALA2094722
- County
- Lancaster County
- School district
- Pequea Valley
- Days on NookLocal
- 28 days
Interior features
- Appliances
- Dishwasher, Oven/Range - Electric
- Flooring
- Carpet, Vinyl, Wood
- Interior features
- Carpet, Dining Area, Kitchen - Country, Kitchen - Island, Window Treatments, Wood Floors
- Fireplace
- 1
- Fireplace type
- Brick, Gas/Propane
- Basement
- Full, Outside Entrance, Partially Finished
- Laundry
- Main Floor
- Levels
- 2
- Accessibility
- None
Exterior & construction
- Construction
- Brick, Masonry
- Roof
- Slate
- Foundation
- Stone
- Exterior features
- Sidewalks
- Patio & porch
- Porch(es), Wrap Around
- Windows
- Insulated, Replacement
- Doors
- Storm
- View
- Limited
Systems & utilities
- Heating fuel
- Oil
- Cooling fuel
- None
- Hot water
- Propane
- Water source
- Well
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- Utilities
- Cable TV Available, Electric Available, Phone Available
Parking
- Parking
- Detached Garage, Driveway, On Street
- Garage type
- Garage - Front Entry, Garage Door Opener
- Parking features
- Paved Driveway
- Total spaces
- 7
- Driveway spaces
- 5
Community
- Subdivision
- NONE AVAILABLE
Lot & zoning
- Lot dimensions
- 0.00 x 0.00
- Lot features
- Landscaping, Level
- Zoning
- RESIDENTIAL
- Cross street
- Lincoln Highway
Included in the sale
- Possession
- Settlement
Price history
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Sep 8, 2026 | Listed for sale | $369,900 |
Price changes are tracked from when NookLocal first indexed this listing; earlier history may not appear. Tax & assessment details are in the section below.
This address was previously listed July 2026 and taken off the market without selling. A new listing restarts the days-on-market clock.
The NookLocal estimate
Estimated value
$385,000
Automated estimate, not an appraisal. Sale records through July 2026.
About this estimate
Based on 10 comparable sales nearby, the Lancaster County assessment ratio, weighted toward the current asking price.
- Current list price
- $369,900
- County assessment implies
- $459,400
- Est. property taxes at today's rates
- $4,591/yr
Comparable Sales
| Address | Closed | Sale price | Bd/Ba | Sqft | Adjusted value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5827 LINCOLN HWY, GAP, PA 17527 | September 2026 | $616,000 | 3/1 | 2,539 | $546,760 |
| 901 HIDDEN HOLLOW DR, GAP, PA 17527 | August 2025 | $510,000 | 4/2 | 2,368 | $472,085 |
| 899 TIMBERLINE DR, GAP, PA 17527 | February 2025 | $500,000 | 4/2 | 2,643 | $406,376 |
| 5250 NEWPORT RD, GAP, PA 17527 | October 2024 | $338,000 | 3/2 | 2,526 | $325,880 |
| 140 LIZ LN, GAP, PA 17527 | June 2026 | $505,000 | 4/2 | 2,228 | $452,662 |
| 781 NEWPORT AVE, GAP, PA 17527 | May 2026 | $400,000 | 3/2 | 2,830 | $333,671 |
Estimated taxes
Estimated at current rates
$4,591 / year
≈ $383 per month
MLS shows (2026)
$4,591
School tax
PEQUEA VALLEY · 16.79 mills (2025-26)
$3,856
County tax
Lancaster County · 3.20 mills (2026)
$735
Municipal tax
As recorded for 2026, varies by municipality
$0
Recomputed from the county assessment ($229,700, 2018 base year) × current millage. School millage is from the latest year certified by the Pennsylvania Department of Education (2025-26); districts adopt the next year's budgets each June, and we update when the state certifies the statewide file in the fall. Portals typically reprint the recorded 2026 bill. Pennsylvania does not reassess on sale. Estimate only. Verify with Lancaster County before relying on it. Learn more: PA property tax calculator · Common Level Ratio by county.
Estimated monthly payment calculator
$73,980 (20%)
6.43%
Loan term
Estimated monthly payment
$2,347/mo
- Principal & interest
- $1,857
- Property taxes (current rates)
- $383
- Home insurance (est.)
- $108
Taxes use NookLocal's estimate at current millage rates, not the stale figure on the MLS. The default rate is the average 30-year rate as of July 2026; insurance is estimated at 0.35% of the price per year. Below 20% down, lenders usually add mortgage insurance, which this estimate doesn't include. Estimate only; verify before relying on it.
Area statistics
School district
Pequea Valley
- Academic index
- 55.5/100
- Graduation rate
- 95.5%
- PSSA ELA proficient
- 48.2%
- PSSA Math proficient
- 39.6%
2025 PA state assessments (PSSA / Keystone) and graduation data. The index measures student outcomes, not school effectiveness, and is not adjusted for demographics. Districts serve all residents; verify enrollment boundaries with the district.
Safety data
Lancaster County crime & safety numbers →
County figures from FBI and Pennsylvania source data.
Property taxes
Lancaster County taxes, explained →
Millage, the Common Level Ratio, and what changes after you buy.
Map location
Open in Google Maps© BRIGHT, All Rights Reserved
Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the BRIGHT Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms in which United Real Estate Strive 212 participates, and is provided by BRIGHT through a licensing agreement.
IDX listings are displayed pursuant to broker of record United Real Estate Strive 212, Frank Ramos, Broker/Owner, PA Broker License RM424345, 1220 Broadcasting Rd, Suite 201, Wyomissing, PA 19610, (610) 372-0212.
The information provided by this website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Some properties which appear for sale on this website may no longer be available because they are under contract, have Closed or are no longer being offered for sale.
Data last updated: October 6, 2026 at 8:15 AM EDT
Homes like this one
Need an agent who gets you?
Our co-founder Carmen does a 1-on-1 needs analysis with you, then hand-picks a vetted Salisbury Township agent or lender. Free, no obligation. If you work with a partner we introduce, NookLocal may earn a referral fee from their broker.